These Amish pumpkin whoopie pies are the perfect fall treat. They are a soft and fluffy sandwich cookie with cream cheese filling.| Two Pink Peonies
These Amish oatmeal whoopie pies are so good. They taste a lot like the prepackaged ones you can buy at the store but better!| Two Pink Peonies
These Amish peanut butter cookies are a big thick peanut butter cookie. They are just like the ones that you’ll find at Amish bakeries.| Two Pink Peonies
These copycat Subway raspberry cheesecake cookies are so good. This easy copycat recipe is sure to be a new favorite!| Two Pink Peonies
These Amish Snickerdoodles are super soft with just the right amount of sugar and cinnamon spice. They are so quick and easy to make too!| Two Pink Peonies
These Chocolate Chip Cookies with Honey are so easy to make. This recipe yields such a soft and chewy cookie thanks to the honey!| Two Pink Peonies
These chocolate chip cookies with apple cider vinegar are my go to cookie recipe. They come out perfect each time!| Two Pink Peonies
These Amish Christmas Cookies are an easy way to get in the Christmas spirit. This old fashioned recipe uses just a few ingredients!| Two Pink Peonies
These Amish funeral cookies have such a sad name but are such a yummy cookie. They are an old fashioned, traditional Amish recipe.| Two Pink Peonies
These old fashioned Amish pumpkin cookies will melt in your mouth. They are so easy to make with no chill time required.| Two Pink Peonies
These Amish oatmeal cookies are not only delicious but they're so easy to make. They are a family favorite!| Two Pink Peonies
These Amish monster cookies are not only delicious but they are so easy to make. They are just like the ones at Amish bakeries.| Two Pink Peonies
This Amish apple cake recipe is perfectly baked in a 9 x 13 pan. It is lightly sweet and is fantastic with a cup of hot tea.| Two Pink Peonies
This Amish coffee cake is an easy old fashioned recipe. This coffee cake uses common pantry ingredients and is amazing with a hot cup of coffee or tea.| Two Pink Peonies
This old fashioned Amish Party Mix is perfect for your next get together! This yummy party mix has all your favorites.| Two Pink Peonies
This Amish banana bread is a simple and wonderful recipe. It will also make your house smell amazing while it bakes.| Two Pink Peonies
These New York Style Chocolate Chip Cookies are an ultra thick chocolate chip cookie just like the kind you see at New York bakeries.| Two Pink Peonies
This Amish pot roast is both super simple and super delicious. It is an easy, old fashioned Amish recipe that your family will love!| Two Pink Peonies
If you love simple and old fashioned recipes then you will love this Amish Chicken Salad recipe. It is an easy Amish recipe.| Two Pink Peonies
This Amish zucchini bread goes great with a cup of hot coffee or tea. This sweet and moist quick bread also smells amazing while it bakes!| Two Pink Peonies
These sourdough chocolate chip cookies are thick, bakery style cookies that you are sure to love.| Two Pink Peonies
These Chunky Chocolate Chip Cookies are the perfect chocolate chip cookie recipe for people who like a thick and chunky, bakery style cookie!| Two Pink Peonies
This Amish Salad Dressing is so easy to make. It is loaded with tons of zippy flavors with some sweet notes. It goes with almost any salad!| Two Pink Peonies