In the paper “Towards a Clear and Fair Conceptualization of Empathy” (2023a), Caroline Bollen sets up a proposal for an anti-discriminatory and explicitly normative notion of empathy. In a reply, Colin Marshall (2023) raised four challenges to her argument—to which Bollen (2023b) responded. We (Bollen and Marshall) continued this discussion in conversation over Zoom, which resulted in this collaborative concluding discussion. … [please read below the rest of the article].| Social Epistemology Review and Reply Collective