Are you wondering what food to make for your toddler’s next party? Here are some cute party food recipes and finger food ideas that might just get the kids to stop playing long enough to eat. Just to prove that I know what toddlers like, check out the results from the twin toddler taste test. Narwhal Donuts Narwhals are the unicorn of the sea. These narwhal donuts are the perfect handheld treat for an under-the-sea themed children’s party.